Sterling Silver vs. Stainless Steel vs. Alloy: Which Metal Is Best for Jewelry?

When shopping for jewelry, it’s easy to focus on design — from the shimmer of a charm to the way it completes an outfit — but the metal behind the beauty is just as important. Not only does it affect the look and feel of a piece, but it also determines how long it lasts, how much care it requires, and how comfortable it is on your skin.

At Lovely Velvet, we specialize in handmade velvet chokers paired with quality metals like sterling silver and stainless steel. We’ve chosen these materials with care — because we believe your jewelry should stay beautiful, hypoallergenic, and durable for years to come.

So how do sterling silver, stainless steel, and alloy/brass jewelry really compare? Let’s dive in.

Sterling Silver Jewelry

Sterling silver has been a favorite in the jewelry world for centuries — and for good reason.

✨ What is sterling silver?

Sterling silver is made of 92.5% pure silver and 7.5% other metals (usually copper) for added strength. That’s why it’s often marked with “925”.

✨ Pros of Sterling Silver:

  • Beautiful shine – Its natural luster gives it that classic, high-end look.
  • Hypoallergenic – Pure silver is gentle on most sensitive skin, making it an excellent choice for everything from earrings and necklaces to everyday jewelry.
  • Timeless value – It is a precious metal that holds long-term worth.
  • Easy to repair & polish – Tarnish can be removed with simple polishing, restoring its glow.

✨ Cons of Sterling Silver:

  • Prone to tarnishing – Exposure to air, humidity, or lotions can darken it over time.
  • Softer metal – Can scratch or bend more easily than steel.
  • More expensive – Pricier than stainless steel or alloy jewelry.

👉 Best For: Heirloom-style jewelry, gifts, and anyone with sensitive skin looking for a timeless piece.

Stainless Steel Jewelry

If you want jewelry that can keep up with daily life, stainless steel might be your perfect match.

✨ What is stainless steel?

Stainless steel is an iron-based alloy mixed with chromium, which makes it extremely durable and resistant to rust.

✨ Pros of Stainless Steel:

  • Highly durable – Won’t easily bend, scratch, or break.
  • Tarnish- and rust-resistant – Keeps its shine with little maintenance.
  • Budget-friendly – More affordable than sterling silver, while still looking sleek and polished.
  • Hypoallergenic – Great for sensitive skin.
  • Low maintenance – No need for constant polishing.

✨ Cons of Stainless Steel:

  • Heavier feel – Some people notice it weighs more than silver or brass.
  • Not a precious metal – It doesn’t hold the same value as sterling silver or gold.

👉 Best For: Everyday wear, long-lasting pieces, and low-maintenance jewelry lovers.

Alloy & Brass Jewelry (Fashion Metals)

Many fast-fashion jewelry brands use alloy or brass — a mixture of different base metals that’s inexpensive and easy to work with.

✨ What is alloy/brass?

Alloys can be made from various metals like copper, zinc, or nickel. Brass, specifically, is made of copper and zinc.

✨ Pros of Alloy/Brass:

  • Affordable – Often the cheapest option on the market.
  • Versatile – Easy to shape, allowing for fun fashion designs.
  • Lightweight – Comfortable for larger pieces.

✨ Cons of Alloy/Brass:

  • Prone to tarnishing – Can darken or change color quickly.
  • May cause irritation – Often contains nickel, which can trigger skin reactions.
  • Less durable – Can bend, dent, or break more easily.
  • Short lifespan – Meant for trendy fashion jewelry, not long-term wear.

👉 Best For: Short-term, inexpensive, or trendy jewelry that you don’t mind replacing.

Why Lovely Velvet Chooses Sterling Silver & Stainless Steel

At Lovely Velvet, we believe your jewelry should look gorgeous and stand the test of time. That’s why we handcraft our chokers with sterling silver and stainless steel findings.

Both metals keep your choker beautiful without turning your skin green or tarnishing too quickly. We intentionally avoid lower-quality metals like cheap alloys or brass because they don’t meet our standards of quality and comfort. Your choker should feel just as luxurious as it looks.

Choosing the Best Metal for Your Jewelry

When it comes to jewelry, the metal truly matters. If you want timeless, hypoallergenic beauty, sterling silver is a wonderful choice. If you prefer durability and low maintenance, stainless steel is a reliable everyday option. And while alloy/brass pieces can be fun for short-term fashion, they won’t last like silver or steel.

At the end of the day, the best metal depends on your lifestyle, skin sensitivity, and how long you want your jewelry to last.

✨ Explore Lovely Velvet’s handmade velvet chokers, crafted with sterling silver and stainless steel — designed to be just as durable as they are beautiful.

Back to blog